TP-Docs
HTML5 Icon HTML5 Icon HTML5 Icon
TP on Social Media

Recent

Welcome to TinyPortal. Please login or sign up.

Members
  • Total Members: 3,972
  • Latest: Lineo
Stats
  • Total Posts: 196,105
  • Total Topics: 21,345
  • Online today: 1,072
  • Online ever: 8,223 (February 19, 2025, 04:35:35 AM)
Users Online
  • Users: 0
  • Guests: 739
  • Total: 739

NJ bill bans anonymous posts on the net

Started by iowamf, March 07, 2006, 05:40:45 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

TwinsX2Dad

Quote from: IchBinÃ,â,,¢ on March 09, 2006, 09:53:00 PM
Simply amazing.... It never ceases to amaze me what kind of laws are in the works. I just read one today about the online freedom of speech act.

It is amazing.

Serious statement: The liberals are behind it all.

Gargoyle

Thanks a lot for letting us know about this.

Gargoyle

Does anyone know what the IP addresses are for new Jersey. Better yet the ranges assigned to the state ?

If this Bill passes I would like to ban the entire state.

TwinsX2Dad

You might want to understand that there are no AOL IP addresses in New Jersey, but there are thousands of AOL customers there.

IP addresses are not geographically assigned and are easily spoofed, redirected and or relayed. While some can be geographically linked, it isn't a certainty.

One of the problems with this bill is it includes traffic on all NJ computer systems. Any time you connect anywhere on the Internet, your data packets could be relayed nearly anywhere. I recall years ago running traceroutes on traffic between a friend in Tucson and me here in the Phoenix area, a driving distance of about 100 miles. Virginia and Washington were common sightings on the reports.

New Jersey is home for many data centers and does relay a lot of information. One of my dedicated servers is located in NJ, another in Virginia and a third in California.

So, if you were to guarantee that NJ stayed out of your traffic loop, you might also be causing issues for a user in Oregon.

Gargoyle

Hmmm... There has to be a way out of this mess that they are attempting to create.

iowamf

#25
IchBin - you are right ... the   OnLine Freedom of Speech Act was in the news and the exemption passed this week.

Fortunately, its got to be the shortest bill of all time ... a whopping one sentence modification to a 1971 bill. It's different from the NJ bill trying to ban anonymous posts - this one is to protect "political talk" on the 'net.

Quote from: TwinsX2Dad on March 10, 2006, 05:49:12 AM
Quote from: IchBinâââ,¬Å¾Ã,¢ on March 09, 2006, 09:53:00 PM
Simply amazing.... It never ceases to amaze me what kind of laws are in the works. I just read one today about the online freedom of speech act.
It is amazing.
Serious statement: The liberals are behind it all.

TwinsXDad - many liberals did try to stop this on-line freedom of speech act - see here - but their efforts were shot down this week with the new bill.  A good wrap up at CNET here - published the day before the bill passed.

My summary is the ones against the Free Speech Act claim to want to protect us out of fear of internet posts being positioned as truth/news - especially in political campaigns. Of course that is a concern, but its not anything new ... hey, "old media" already does this - just don't ask CBS/Dan Blather to admit they forge stories and documents and try to pass it off as news.

My $0.02 is we already have Freedom of Speech and this bill is not needed. I'm glad it passed - but even letting it pass implies the gov't can regulate political content on the net.

The ones wanting regulation are trying to stop the new media's onslaught of the old media. Note how the NYTimes wants regulations on the 'net in the articles linked to above.

QuoteLiberal advocacy groups circulated letters warning the measure was too broad and would invite "corrupt" activities online, and The New York Times wrote in an editorial this week that "the Internet would become a free-fire zone without any limits on spending."

Some readers may not think this info is relevant - but without this exemption once a blog (or a forum like this) reached 500 readers in a 30-day period or pulled in over $250/yr the website would have been subject to 100's of pages of regulations and potential campaign finance laws (fines!) - that would have sucked (and increased the size of gov't to insane new levels). 

500 readers in a 30-day period or over $250/yr is not a very high threshold to cross - and look how easy politics can show-up ... even if you are not trying to start a political thread :)

TwinsX2Dad

If the liberals had their way, news/talk radio would be history. Gone would be Rush Limbaugh, Sean Hannity, Michael Reagan, Tony Snow, G Gordon Liddy, and other preachers of the church of the painful truth.

Gone too would be all of the blogs reporting reality and conservative views. The Christian stand would be even less represented.

Democrat, Liberal, Left-Wing, Communist, Socialist, Oppression - these are all literally grouped together.

Conservative, Freedom, Strength, Prosperity, Morality, Liberty, Personal Responsibility - these are all literally grouped together.

Any questions?   ;D

This website is proudly hosted on Crocweb Cloud Website Hosting.