Feed Back Visual Confirm?

[JCphotog]

I like music!  On the 4th beat what note was played!  Whoooha.  Only those with perfect pitch may enter this page!  And we'll do something tricky like bartok.  ok ok I know..  I'd still like to know how to require an answer in order to post a form....

[akulion]

well dreaming aside, lets first atleast get captcha working

[JCphotog]

That would be great.  I have an email form working, but no captcha.  I've been all over carnagie mellon's captcha site.  The do a great description of it, but I don't see where to download anything..   I like their new version with 4 pictures of similar things too.  Though text is the simplest

[JCphotog]

What do you think of these guys.  I'm still looking for a good captcha script.   

http://www.motobit.com/util/captcha/

--Jesse

[akulion]

ASP with PHP ?

dont have the knowledge to say if it can work or not really

[JCphotog]

Maybe taking a step backwards? Did you have any luck finding a better captcha?

[akulion]

no i stopped looking after i kept stumbling on dud script after dud script

its so frustrating to install something and then find out its either PLAGUED with adverts or simply dosent want to work no matter what you do and to top it off there are no support forums lol

[JCphotog]

Yes.  That is a pain in the @s$   .  I've been looking to, and I haven't been to happy with what I've found.  I wonder if there is some way to do this through the forum.  There's a captcha like script involved the registration, and email capabilities..

[akulion]

u can do it by placing the feedback form inside a block or article

and then restricting it for registered members only
that way bots who are seen as 'guests' wont be able to fill it out

[JCphotog]

That's a good method.  I do get a lot of non spam feed back though from non registered users.  I worry that by doing this I'd restrict a bit of information.  Possibly the suggested text version creating a required question, like what is this forum about, dogs, cats, or art?  Any thought on how I could code something like this into the form?