All right my friends, now I know that we all discussed this issue not too long ago, but I really need to tell you all what I found out just today at a meeting with some web developers and hosting companies. I went to this meeting to get some incite on what is new and what is going on in the world of development, and an interesting topic was brought to the attention of everyone in the room.
There are a few hosting companies that are complaining that they have came across some of the customers using a jukebox in their site for some of the members, most of these sites are? Yes you guessed it, forums, and a few that were mostly informational sites, the problem is that some of these host are being contacted by the RIAA and being forced to take action about people using their sites as a platform to share music with others. If these host do not either pull the sites, or completely delete the files that are being shared they too will be liable for any lawsuits that might arise from them coming after the owner of the website or in some cases going after the host for letting their customers use their sites in that fashion.
The question of the day was, â€Ã...“Is it illegal to share music within your website, and is it illegal to use a jukebox as such?â€Ã, The answer to that question came from a gentleman who was seated in the back, and in his words, you are still sharing music with others, and broadcasting it over an open line for everyone to listen to, this falls under the broadcasting laws, and if you intend to share any type of music, you must have a license to do so, or you could be held liable for these actions. One question was asked, â€Ã...“If you are not offering them as a download, what difference does it makeâ€Ã,Â? Answer, it doesn’t matter, you are still sharing copyright protected material, the law is the law and there is no sense in arguing about it because you can’t win.
I am starting to see more and more of these as time goes by, and yes I am starting to see more and more websites mostly forums offer their members something to listen to while they are present in a forum area, my feelings about this is very negative, and I feel that we should be able to put anything in our websites, but I would never offer a download to anyone because of these reasons.
My question was, I know that it is illegal to do this, and I do understand the reason why, but do you really think that the RIAA is going to go after a person who only offers a little amount of songs on their website for people to listen to, compared to the people who openly offer music in the forum of a download, who do you think they stand to make more money from? Surly not the little guy who isn’t offering any downloadsâ€Ã, Answer: the problem is the same as listening to music on the radio, if you copy a song from the radio you are doing something that illegal, because you are making a copy of a copy written song, it is just that simple. He went on, if you were to pull into a parking lot, and opened up your car doors and started playing music for all of your friends, do you think it would be illegal? You might think so, but you are in a controlled area, and you are only playing songs over a loud system, and in most cases if someone was there trying to record those songs, that is the only time it would be illegal, but other then that you are free to do so, however if you were to do the same in a forum area, you are making it possible more for people to record what you are offering, which is very illegal and as illegal as heck. You have to remember, the laws are the laws, and we no matter how much we try can argue all day long, but it still isn’t going to change that at all.
The chances of you getting caught is very slim, but never the less, if you are willing to take that gamble, go right ahead, but if they want they can come in and take everything you own, and put you away for a long time.
My personal view!!! This is crap!!! And I want to hear what others have to say about this issue.
Dang you just can’t do anything anymore!
Told you so :)
As for being caught, we'll be ok, but your top of the watch list now after attending that meeting :)
QuoteThis is crap!!!
...but unless you have $50 billion to take on corperate America then your going to have to get used to it.
If I was you I'd be more worried about http://www.macroberts.com/view_item.aspx?item_id=4114
and being forced to hand over your members details or go to jail for doing nothing!
Ah yes I have already heard about this little issue. I don't know about the rest of you, but this is going to come more and more as time goes by, mainly because people are just getting sick and tired of how some forums don't take great care in protecting their members. An open forum is a open forum, and if there are no rules for members to follow you can bet your pants that someone is going to get hurt, and even if you have rules to follow it doesn't mean that it is going to totally protect them from harm.
We have to face it there are people out here who will do anything just to make people mad, and will say anything to get their point across to others, and that is why some of these laws are starting to be inforced more. I truly beleive that a person should have the right to say anything in a forum, however I don't think that it is good to go and give personal information about a person over the net just because you are made at that person. Case in point, there is a very popular website here in Michigan, it is called www.mlive.com if you go to the forums areas any person can make up a number of names, and say anything about another person and it will go un-noticed, however the company that does take care of this site does moderate it as much as possible, but the problem is that they can't handle all of it, and that site is filled with the best of trouble makers that are out there on the net, and the hard truth is that most of these people don't even live in Michigan.
In my forums, I don't tolerate, and abuse, no bashing, no name calling, and so on, I won't ban a person at first, but if the trouble keeps going on, they will be gone, but yet I can't fight them on my own either. Not long ago I had one person that started trouble in my site, and this person was from the mlive.com that got wind of my site and their only motive was to try to upset other members in the site, which they did, and even went as far as giving more personal information to other members about the person they were attacking.
First off, I don't care who you are, you don't go and cause problems just because someone doesn't always agree with you on any topic, and if someone doesn't like what you say, you surly don't have to start finding out IP addresses, and tracking people and finding out personal information to use againest them in the forum, that is not only childish, but just isn't right. One person can cause a lot of problems in a forum, and not only that can really upset more then just that.
I also find it funny that some people will spend so much time pursuing one person, just to get even. That is why I won't let things like that happen, not in my site I won't. I won't because I want my members to feel comfortable, and want to come back, but you always can't do that, because in some areas you have to really look at both sides. It is like this, lets say I have a close friend who joins my site, and become very active, then one day, some one says something that they don't agree with and they ask me to pull their comment or even to ban them from the site, first off I can't take sides no matter who they are, because if you do that then you are not a good host, taking sides is a bad bad thing to do, because then you are only pushing a person away just because they don't like what the other says, and I even tell my mods that, you can't never take sides, you can post a comment, but when it comes to a argument of any kind, you need to keep free from that, and if you pull one post you had better pull both.