TinyPortal

General => Chit chat => Topic started by: WSA on July 05, 2006, 05:20:31 PM

Title: vBulletin Switch?
Post by: WSA on July 05, 2006, 05:20:31 PM
I have used vBulletin in the past and always thought it was fine.  Since this hacker team has been wreaking havoc around the various TP boards, my partner has asked me to do something that will prevent all of this.

In regards to our relationship with Western Slope Anglers, we both collaborated the idea to create it and so we both are 50/50 partners.

I usually handle all of the computer related stuff though.  Initially when when we started, the question came up as to which software we wanted to use for the forum.  I initially suggested that we use vBulletin as I was familiar with it.  We didn't have enough money to get it though so we went with SMF.  He was very apprehensive about it because it was a free service but I assured him that I researched it and was extremely confident that SMF would be able to handle what we wanted it to.

Now, since the hacker blitz, I am getting a bunch of told you so's and what the heck are you thinking?  I am still saying that SMF is the way to go but he is adamant about me switching us over to vBulletin or another pay forum.

What are your opinions on this and what can I tell him to allay his fears about the hack?

I don't really want to switch over but he is my partner and I have to respect his opinions and fears.
Title: Re: vBulletin Switch?
Post by: G6Cad on July 05, 2006, 05:26:52 PM
Can only say that you should tell your friends to browse around the vbulletin boars and read about the hacks they are been through the last year only.
i know several sites that have vbulletin and they been hacked to, so even if SMF is a free ware and Vbulletin payed for, it doesent say you are clear of hackers.
hackers will always find ways to hack sites, it's what they do and what they think is fun.

So IMHO i think it doesent matter if you use a payed or free forum or site scripts. They will get hacked no matter what.
Title: Re: vBulletin Switch?
Post by: gerrymo on July 05, 2006, 05:27:45 PM
They are not hacks as such. They are spammers. The patches released by Bloc will take care of this. There are also more features in the next release that will also help.
Title: Re: vBulletin Switch?
Post by: IchBin on July 05, 2006, 05:28:18 PM
First of all you can tell him that it had nothing to do with SMF and everything to do with TinyPortal. Especially in the up coming releases, there are a ton of features added. Nothing is perfect, so if he would like to take a look at Forums that have had exploits and hacks I can definately show him that VBulletin has had their problems.
You can also tell him their isn't a portal around that is as Tiny, Fast, and customisable as TinyPortal. Not only do you "NOT" have to pay for it, but its features will far outway most portals out there. If you're not making a "living" off your site and you're always donating to charity it's a no brainer if you ask me. But, as always you should stay UP TO DATE on our forum/portal software.
Title: Re: vBulletin Switch?
Post by: WSA on July 05, 2006, 06:02:46 PM
Ok, I called him again and discussed it all over with him.  Now he is doing the searching.

vBulletin with VBAdvanced as the CMP.

I'll keep you updated.
Title: Re: vBulletin Switch?
Post by: IchBin on July 05, 2006, 06:48:38 PM
A simple google search for vbulletin exploits will bring up pages of info. You can pretty much do that with most software. Nothing is perfect.
Title: Re: vBulletin Switch?
Post by: Xarcell on July 05, 2006, 07:18:45 PM
I wanna cover more of what Ichbin said. It's a  TP issue, not SMF.

TP is in beta stage, the possibility of this was likely sooner or later.

Bloc posted a patch to the hack long time ago. It could have been pervented on your end.

vbulletin has alot of the same issues. The hack you seen is actually a hack idea used for other portals. I've even seen it on mkportal(1 year ago) and postnuke(3 years ago).

Just ask yourself, which has the most potential? Which is gonna fit more of what I need? Cost's on vbulletin ain't that bad to be honest, but I chose SMF because of it's development consistency. I found TP later and realized that before everything is said and done, Bloc will have developed the best portal software out there-thanks to SMF.

I believe everyone will be switching to TP/SMF for their portal solution by the holidays/early 07.

-Xarcell
Title: Re: vBulletin Switch?
Post by: gerrymo on July 05, 2006, 07:35:40 PM
Xarcell, when this goes gold with the first public release, it will take LOADS away from other portals. No doubt about it. Add to that the Gallery, Link manager, and the 1st to be released (late this month) Feline's Blog Mod (she very kindly allowed me a look at it) its going to be awasome, very early on. And of course, not forgetting Bloc's planned additions, tweeks, etc.

This is going to become a very busy site.
Title: Re: vBulletin Switch?
Post by: alan s on July 05, 2006, 07:50:42 PM
Maybe this will convince your partner , http://milw0rm.com/video/watch.php?id=30   ,   this is some guy hacking vB
Title: Re: vBulletin Switch?
Post by: WSA on July 05, 2006, 08:38:17 PM
I understand which has the most potential and I have been nothing but happy with SMF and with everybody who helps out here.  You all have helped me out so much and not with the cheezy IT guy attitudes either.

I will show him that video and continue to talk with him.  He trusts my opinions but he is completely in the "I told you so" mode right now.
Title: Re: vBulletin Switch?
Post by: WSA on July 05, 2006, 08:40:11 PM
Quote from: Alan S on July 05, 2006, 07:50:42 PM
Maybe this will convince your partner , http://milw0rm.com/video/watch.php?id=30   ,   this is some guy hacking vB
Jeez, I don't even understand what that guy is doing.
Title: Re: vBulletin Switch?
Post by: alan s on July 05, 2006, 09:39:50 PM
lol your not the only one as far as i can guess hes inserting some script into the site and stealing lisences and getting control of the forum?
Title: Re: vBulletin Switch?
Post by: IchBin on July 05, 2006, 10:22:10 PM
I just read about this stuff the other day. People stealing sessions. It looked to me like you stole an account by stealing the session and MD5 some how. That's crazy!
Title: Re: vBulletin Switch?
Post by: bloc on July 05, 2006, 10:29:47 PM
Barely got what he is doing too..it does seem he exploits all text fields not being checked. I think maybe vb.com use(or used ) a lot of diferent scripts for different things - and that they not always are equally thourough. But I maybe understood it wrong.

In that respect SMF and TP are a step ahead: since everything depends on SMF member management/session checks, nothing is running "on their own".
Title: Re: vBulletin Switch?
Post by: WSA on July 05, 2006, 10:59:31 PM
Alrighty boys and girls.  I have him kind of cooled off now.  Looks like we will be staying with SMF/TP.  :D  :D
Title: Re: vBulletin Switch?
Post by: Techdomain on July 05, 2006, 11:15:24 PM
Quote from: gerrymo on July 05, 2006, 07:35:40 PM
Xarcell, when this goes gold with the first public release, it will take LOADS away from other portals. No doubt about it. Add to that the Gallery, Link manager, and the 1st to be released (late this month) Feline's Blog Mod (she very kindly allowed me a look at it) its going to be awasome, very early on. And of course, not forgetting Bloc's planned additions, tweeks, etc.

This is going to become a very busy site.

I have in the last few months considered moving to another portal that meets my needs more - however, having a look at the roadmap and the improvements mentioned even in 0.9.5 I am hanging on... when the next release happens, TP will definately be the best portal solution for an SMF site!
Title: Re: vBulletin Switch?
Post by: WSA on July 05, 2006, 11:22:09 PM
Yeah, that's what I expressed to him also.  SMF/TP are both on the right road.

Just hoping that RC 1.1 and TP 1.0 become completely stable so I don't have to worry about this stuff anymore.

He tried to make me promise that nothing like this would happen again and I told him I couldn't.  Anybody can hack into anywhere if they really want to.  He doesn't exactly understand so hopefully nothing like this happens again or he will be wanting to go to vBulletin and will be more diffucult to dissuade.

I do have a few plans to ensure that he won't want to go that way.  I need to invest some more money into our forums in order to say that we can't change now, we have too much invested in it.  :)
Title: Re: vBulletin Switch?
Post by: Techdomain on July 05, 2006, 11:27:32 PM
Well - there is no such thing as 100% stable and hack proof software... what is important is the community/developers reactions to those problems (ie fix asap) as well as their ability to read the market needs and implement them. Top marks so far to TP/SMF in my book on both counts!