TinyPortal

General => Chit chat => Topic started by: iowamf on March 14, 2006, 01:59:28 AM

Title: v0.9 - wow! I bet v1.0 does not come until SMF bumps to a non RC level
Post by: iowamf on March 14, 2006, 01:59:28 AM
I wonder when SMF plans to bump 1.1 RC2 to the next level?  :-\

I don't know what Bloc's plans are for v1.0 - but I don't think we should expect (or want) a 1.0 until SMF 1.1 is no longer a release candidate (unless SMF has a history of ice-age duration RC testing periods).

Any SMF old-timers care to opine on SMF's naming conventions and predictions for RC1.2 going to a non release candidate? I'm a newbie and am clueless on past history.

I have a sneaking suspicion Bloc knows more about SMF milestones than we do and the fact that this site just went to v0.9 is a good thing ;)
Title: Re: v0.9 - wow! I bet v1.0 does not come until SMF bumps to a non RC level
Post by: anunlike on March 14, 2006, 03:08:58 AM
My prediction is it'll be out in a month or so. I'm not on the staff or anything, but I've heard a couple of people who are, about a month ago say that it was delayed due to some UTF-8 problems and will be out in a couple months or so. Mind you, that's just a guess. They talked as if normally it'd be out by now.

But, my guess is that SMF will be out shortly, long before TP 1.0 gets out.

Any new version of TP is a good thing. ;)
Title: Re: v0.9 - wow! I bet v1.0 does not come until SMF bumps to a non RC level
Post by: eldacar on March 14, 2006, 05:46:17 AM
Indeed, it will still be a little while further. There have been some serious bugs that need fixing, as well as the Internationilzation issues mentioned by anunlike.
Title: Re: v0.9 - wow! I bet v1.0 does not come until SMF bumps to a non RC level
Post by: iowamf on March 14, 2006, 09:05:57 AM
I know the stock answer is it will be ready when it is ready - and that is fine by me.

The feedback is great though - it is good to know the issues.

Outside of the FF1.5/keepalive serious bug - I'm not up to speed on the other "serious bugs that need fixing" ... is there a list of these at smf.org?

Seeing the portal get a ".9" in the version is a great thing - congrats to Bloc & team.
Title: Re: v0.9 - wow! I bet v1.0 does not come until SMF bumps to a non RC level
Post by: eldacar on March 14, 2006, 01:48:13 PM
The development server itself is in pretty bad shape which is also slowing development. Internationization is the big one I think though. The devs want to get it perfect for release.
Title: Re: v0.9 - wow! I bet v1.0 does not come until SMF bumps to a non RC level
Post by: Xarcell on March 14, 2006, 01:58:58 PM
Bloc is a pretty smart guy, I'm sure his intentions are not to release 1.0 until smf1.1 final is released.

Ontop of everything, IE7 is due for release pretty soon too, which may complicate things more. I dunno...

I guess we have to wait and see...
Title: Re: v0.9 - wow! I bet v1.0 does not come until SMF bumps to a non RC level
Post by: IchBin on March 14, 2006, 02:51:31 PM
I'm personally not worried about IE7. If they can't get it right by now, they have some serious issues.
Title: Re: v0.9 - wow! I bet v1.0 does not come until SMF bumps to a non RC level
Post by: alan s on March 14, 2006, 04:14:34 PM
i wont be using IE7...........................firefox all the way like
Title: Re: v0.9 - wow! I bet v1.0 does not come until SMF bumps to a non RC level
Post by: iowamf on March 14, 2006, 04:47:54 PM
My point is that it is looking like SMF releasing a non RC version is going to be on the critical path.

My point had nothing to do w/ Bloc's (obvious) level of intellect - even if Bloc can turn lead into gold - it won't matter if SMF is stuck in RC mode. 

Quote from: Xarcell on March 14, 2006, 01:58:58 PM
Bloc is a pretty smart guy, I'm sure his intentions are not to release 1.0 until smf1.1 final is released.
Title: Re: v0.9 - wow! I bet v1.0 does not come until SMF bumps to a non RC level
Post by: gerrymo on March 14, 2006, 04:56:57 PM
It probably comes down to whether SMF plan any major changes for the final release or not. If it's only bug fixes etc, then there is nothing to hold back TP 1.0, if there are to be big chages at SMF, there would be no point in doing TP 1.0 until after SMF is out.

Simple really.
Title: Re: v0.9 - wow! I bet v1.0 does not come until SMF bumps to a non RC level
Post by: anunlike on March 14, 2006, 04:59:29 PM
From my understanding, they're just fixing things, and it'll be out in a bit.
Title: Re: v0.9 - wow! I bet v1.0 does not come until SMF bumps to a non RC level
Post by: TwinsX2Dad on March 14, 2006, 07:31:04 PM
Quote from: anunlike on March 14, 2006, 04:59:29 PM
they're just fixing things

Let's get together a glue collection. That might help them fix things!

Think of it this way. SMF 1.1 & TP 1.0 will not make a difference. TP 0.9 isn't even out yet. But as soon as these things come, everyone will be clamoring for what's next.

Aw gee......when will 1.2 beta 93 be here??? Ooooh, oooooh, the RC is here, the RC is here!

It works now. If you spent less time worrying about it, you might actually miss the first few error riddled releases and get the thing on day three after all of the other poor saps have to upgrade three times in 24 hours!  :
Title: Re: v0.9 - wow! I bet v1.0 does not come until SMF bumps to a non RC level
Post by: G6Cad on March 14, 2006, 08:21:36 PM
Off topic sorry for that but i have to ask....TwinsX2Dad.. Something wrong today? You are really at it today in your posts here today.  Usually your posts are helpfull and nice, but i dont recognize you today.
I can be like that to sometimes.. A cup of tea and a warm bath often helps with the annoying feelings inside, and Im usually in a really good mood after taking care of my soul a bit and had some relaxing :)
Title: Re: v0.9 - wow! I bet v1.0 does not come until SMF bumps to a non RC level
Post by: TwinsX2Dad on March 14, 2006, 08:29:22 PM
No - I am sorry. While I am trying to be my normal self, I am being attacked through PMs and email by a couple of people here - one claims to be something they are not and that is proven by their hurtful actions.

My previous post was intended to be somewhat of a eye opener. I do feel we spend too much time looking for what is coming up instead of enjoying what we have. For a developer, like Bloc or whomever, this is a constant reminder that what you've done just isn't good enough.

I am actually considering dumping the whole thing and going with a purchased solution for my sites.
Title: Re: v0.9 - wow! I bet v1.0 does not come until SMF bumps to a non RC level
Post by: IchBin on March 14, 2006, 10:58:47 PM
I have an idea!

Lets just chaulk this one up as, "I've had a bad day." Then, tomorrow we all come back in a good mood because we refuse to have another bad day.!  :)

I have to say that I do see your point Twins about being grateful for what we have, and not for what is to come. Unfortunately, not everyone is on the same page sometimes. Its ok, I'm sure if Bloc has enough he will say so. :D
Title: Re: v0.9 - wow! I bet v1.0 does not come until SMF bumps to a non RC level
Post by: Xarcell on March 14, 2006, 11:17:11 PM
No one was pushing for the next release of TP and/or SMF.

I personally will be using 1.1 for quite awhile. Especially once all the mod's are updated. Even if there is a 1.2beta...

I heard through the grapevine, that smf final will have some very minor changes. Even template files. That could mean changes for TP. I'd hate to see tp 1.0 be released, then smf1.1 final relased causing TP to be updated to work. Even though is very unlikely due to timing.

IE I'm not all that worried about either, except they will be updating to full support for CSS2. The way the browser reads CSS compared to FF could mean template changes will be needed for it to render identical for both browsers. They also plan to support transparency for .png's, in which I will change all my transparent gif's to png when IE is released. In fact, most of my themes already have the png version. All I have to due is change the extension of the image in my template or stylesheet.

These things are not something that can't e squashed easly, however I believe there will be squashing. I think it would be wiser to wait...

I suspect that Bloc will release v9 to alpha testers in maybe a week or so.
Title: Re: v0.9 - wow! I bet v1.0 does not come until SMF bumps to a non RC level
Post by: iowamf on March 15, 2006, 12:01:57 AM
Amen - I'm 100% grateful for what we have - but that does not mean we cannot look forward to a bright future.

Being grateful for a bright future in no way should imply that past work is "not good enough" in fact, just the opposite.  I think it is all in your perspective.

To be absolutely fair to great developers though, they do get caught in a bind because the better they do - the higher the expectations become ... but that is a good problem to have.

Quote from: Xarcell on March 14, 2006, 11:17:11 PM
No one was pushing for the next release of TP and/or SMF.

Thanks Xarcell ... and to take it further - I was pushing "back" on TP 1.0 expectations ... but I am still curious about the secret decoder rings for SMF releases (alpha, beta, RC1, RC2, RCx, silver, gold, xyz - is there a SMF roadmap like this site has?).

PS - This project has a great roadmap, support and point releases we can hardly keep up with - no complaints here.
Title: Re: v0.9 - wow! I bet v1.0 does not come until SMF bumps to a non RC level
Post by: TwinsX2Dad on March 15, 2006, 12:10:08 AM
I think everyone might have misunderstood my intent. I was only trying to soften expectations for a release time and capabilities.

You see, there always seems to be that push to get the next greatest toy, when we haven't stopped to enjoy what we have. It wasn't a butt-chewing post. It was a reminder that this thing, this SMF/TP thing, is far beyond anything we dreamed of, just 15 years ago. AND IT IS FREE!

You don't even want to know what I used to pay for MajorBBS and RipTerm server software - let's just say that with the same amount of money, you could buy two IPBs, a couple of vBs and toss in some copyright removal fees......

Here's what I would like to see....

Instead of all of the new toys, maybe some definite improvements on the current ones. Make everything simpler to install and have a wider variety of dummy proof theme options. Back in 2000, I was running several sites using Infopop's OpenTopic and Ultimate Bulletin Board software. With OT, Infopop hosted that, so install was truly stupid-proof, but UBB was much the same, except for being hosted on your own server. It installed more easily than what we have today.

As for themes, you could choose from several templates - there were more UBB templates than there are SMF themes today - and in the ACP were selectable color palettes. Point at a color in your UBB and it would tell you which setting applied to that, much like you might see in modern graphics suites. Of course, this was something which should have been expected, considering the cost of the software - but still, if this free thing is all that great, why are we light years behind what was available 5-6 years ago?

There is so much pressure to add this block and that shoutbox and marquee BB Codes that many of the basic features are left behind.

Take a look at the problems caused by the package manager even - sure it is a great thing, but what of the conflicts from different mods? As simple as php is, you'd think it might be done better than what Microsoft & Apple accomplish with their ultra-complex operating systems.

So no, I wasn't coming down on anyone. It just seems like we spend far too much time pushing for the next big thing - then when it comes, all of our themes quit working and all of our mods start acting up. It might be fun for us who like to figure out puzzles, but what do the members think? After awhile, they begin to wonder......

Here's an idea - if you see me write something that isn't in direct confrontation with someone over a mistake/error, before you interpret my intentions, try to imagine just how wide my grin is. You see, I look at most anything which isn't harming another as an opportunity. Any day that God blesses me with is a day I should not only be thankful for, it is a day I can spend helping someone else. If the only assistance I can provide is reminding you to smile, then so be it.
Title: Re: v0.9 - wow! I bet v1.0 does not come until SMF bumps to a non RC level
Post by: bloc on March 15, 2006, 12:25:38 AM
A somewhat strange turn this topic took...;D but also interesting to read.

As for what SMF will have/not have, it is a release candidate, meaning only bugfixes will be done unless some critical updates is necessary. Thats the purpose of RC versions.

TinyPortal will follow its own path though...so while its nice to have SMF/TP coming at the same time, it will depend on how things goes with TP more so than with SMF. But of course, if I can make it less stressful in terms of updates the better. As for the point of "the grass is always greener on the other side of the fence" :) , its always like that...so I try to focus on what vision I have for it, and not stray too much from it.
Title: Re: v0.9 - wow! I bet v1.0 does not come until SMF bumps to a non RC level
Post by: iowamf on March 15, 2006, 12:45:56 AM
Fair enough ... I did not understand your post in the manner below:

Quote from: TwinsX2Dad on March 15, 2006, 12:10:08 AM
I think everyone might have misunderstood my intent. I was only trying to soften expectations for a release time and capabilities.

Especially since the original post was exactly the same as your stated intent:

Quote from: iowamf on March 14, 2006, 01:59:28 AM
I don't think we should expect (or want) a 1.0 until SMF 1.1 is no longer a release candidate

Lets agree we were both trying to soften expectations for a future release and focus on stability before adding new whiz-bangs - but mine was more obvious :)
Title: Re: v0.9 - wow! I bet v1.0 does not come until SMF bumps to a non RC level
Post by: TwinsX2Dad on March 15, 2006, 01:06:20 AM
Fair enough there.

At the same time, I think we've been on the same side of this from the start - I just use more words to confuse folks with!

Now, if I could only figure out which of my kids took my Coke......   :knuppel2:
Title: Re: v0.9 - wow! I bet v1.0 does not come until SMF bumps to a non RC level
Post by: IchBin on March 15, 2006, 05:42:11 AM
Quote from: TwinsX2Dad on March 15, 2006, 01:06:20 AM
Now, if I could only figure out which of my kids took my Coke......   :knuppel2:

Ahh... the simple things in life. Now, go give that KID A BEATING! :D :P
Title: Re: v0.9 - wow! I bet v1.0 does not come until SMF bumps to a non RC level
Post by: TwinsX2Dad on March 15, 2006, 08:29:27 AM
Turned around and my Coke was gone.

Before I could do anything about it, my daughter came around the corner with a full glass. She said, "Dad, I noticed your Coke was almost empty, so I got you more."

Yes, the simple things with attentive nine-year-old girls who love their daddy.......

So, no beatings today.

Unless one of the members here want to volunteer.......
Title: Re: v0.9 - wow! I bet v1.0 does not come until SMF bumps to a non RC level
Post by: bloc on March 15, 2006, 12:10:49 PM
lol :)
Title: Re: v0.9 - wow! I bet v1.0 does not come until SMF bumps to a non RC level
Post by: IchBin on March 15, 2006, 02:40:30 PM
Kids are so awesome. I have a 21 month old girl named Holli. Shes just starting to jabber like crazy now. She goes around giving things to people and then says, "Dank doo holli!"  thanking herself.  lol
Title: Re: v0.9 - wow! I bet v1.0 does not come until SMF bumps to a non RC level
Post by: G6Cad on March 15, 2006, 06:10:42 PM
Thats the beuty of having kids :)   
Sometimes you just want to escape from it all, and then they do something you dont expect, and you just know you love them no matter what they do :D
Title: Re: v0.9 - wow! I bet v1.0 does not come until SMF bumps to a non RC level
Post by: bloc on March 16, 2006, 01:13:29 PM
So true. Got 3 with birthdays all now in march and april..so the activity is an alltime high. :) But its fun too, especially between the 2 and 6 year old recently. She(the older) tries to be "mom" for him, and he just sees straight threw her... ::) But cute nonetheless.
Title: Re: v0.9 - wow! I bet v1.0 does not come until SMF bumps to a non RC level
Post by: crip on March 16, 2006, 01:37:36 PM
Kids..i want some..3, maybe 5..i wish.. :(
Title: Re: v0.9 - wow! I bet v1.0 does not come until SMF bumps to a non RC level
Post by: Nokonium on March 16, 2006, 02:33:50 PM
I've got a 16 year old you can have ...... ;)
Title: Re: v0.9 - wow! I bet v1.0 does not come until SMF bumps to a non RC level
Post by: Mitch on March 16, 2006, 02:47:45 PM
Quote from: nokonium on March 16, 2006, 02:33:50 PM
I've got a 16 year old you can have ...... ;)

That makes me laugh cause I was just thinking about crip telling the guy he had a cute granddaughter. So Ya LMAO
Title: Re: v0.9 - wow! I bet v1.0 does not come until SMF bumps to a non RC level
Post by: G6Cad on March 16, 2006, 03:37:38 PM
QuoteI've got a 16 year old you can have ......

i have 4 children, Two teens ( 15 and 13 this April ) and two minors 6 year and 11 month. The 6year old want to be a BIG boy one minute, stay up late as the teens, go to the disco as the teens do, for the next minute be that tiny little fellow still in diper and mommy at hand all the time :)

The teens want to be grownups, they act as grownups and have pretty much an adult point of view in a lot of things, but still they are as the 6 year old, small tiny people when something isent that funny to do or be a part of :)
They just hated when i got this new baby, MOM, We want our new flat, we had enough from the 6 years old.
But now, they are like me and my husband to the smaller ones. They think itÂÃ,´s kind of fun and cosy to have the small ones hanging arround, and the firts they ask for when they come home from school are the little brothers.

Most of the time it's a rush during the day, but somehow, i cant even emagine to NOT have them arround. They fill up the heart and the meaning of life.  :)
Title: Re: v0.9 - wow! I bet v1.0 does not come until SMF bumps to a non RC level
Post by: crip on March 16, 2006, 04:20:45 PM
Great for you g6cad..sounds awesome. :)