TinyPortal

General => Chit chat => Topic started by: lebisol on October 11, 2007, 10:30:53 PM

Poll
Question: Do you find "Donate" button to be shameless begging?
Title: Donate Button Does Good
Post by: lebisol on October 11, 2007, 10:30:53 PM
Ok, so no one would sit on the street and beg for $.
So why do it on your site?
Does anyone get any donations?
yes, your content is great but how many people really take time?
Doesn't this make your site look 'not so proffessional'?
...just curious
Thanks!
Title: Re: Donate Button Does Good
Post by: Dazed on October 11, 2007, 11:38:18 PM
Having a donation button, block, link or whatever in my opinion is not begging. We have an SMF / TP gaming site and as such spend a great deal of time, money, and effort running it. We have 3 game servers, voice communication, file and map downloads; rather large ones, and see no issue at all to give the option for our users and visitors to contribute. Sometimes we ask our users to contribute as a reminder that all these things cost money. It isn't a requirement but it does help to spread the cost out. *** And yes, we do get a fair amount of donations. Still does not pay for everything but it sure helps.
Title: Re: Donate Button Does Good
Post by: lebisol on October 12, 2007, 01:28:17 AM
Right, but would you sit at the corner street and ask "can I have a $1.00 to help run my site".
Hmmm probably  not.

Don't get me wrong, I will probably end up with one- hey free $ why not if users find content usefull, I am just being devil's advocate  >:D...'asking' feels...wrong. LOL
Thanks the the input, this is kind of a comment I was hoping to get!
Thanks [cbl]Drifter 
Title: Re: Donate Button Does Good
Post by: ApplianceJunk on October 12, 2007, 01:47:56 AM
At first we tried the paypal donate button.
Then after the first month the check came from our affiliate. :)

It was not much, but more then we had got from any paypal donation, as the donations were at $0.00

The second affiliate check come and it was bigger then the first.
We get a affiliate check every two weeks and each one has been bigger then the last.

After a couple of affiliate checks and still no paypal donation we decided to remove the paypal donate button from our site.

Our site is only a few months old and we have a long way to go, but at this point we feel the affiliate ad we use is a much better way to go then the paypal donate button.



Title: Re: Donate Button Does Good
Post by: bloc on October 12, 2007, 02:05:01 AM
Affiliate links is about making money upon traffic directed elsewhere..so I guess donating is more honest to me. At least then I am not making money of what people click on. And if donating doesn't pay any bills..so what? Its not about the money anyway....more like tokens of appreciation.
Title: Re: Donate Button Does Good
Post by: ApplianceJunk on October 12, 2007, 02:16:58 AM
QuoteDoesn't this make your site look 'not so proffessional'?

Depends on how it's done. The donate button here on tinyporstals.net looks good.

I don't like it when the donate button, link, etc.. is every place. Such as in sig lines, at the end of post and a button in a block.

Same with the affiliate. We tried to work with a affiliate that went with our forums.
Being a appliance repair forum the affiliate we decide to work with sold appliance parts.

We don't get paid per click, but a percent of the sales made though out site.
The ads we have up also give people a useful service by letting them enter there model number and view parts diagrams for free. They don't have by anything to do this.

QuoteAffiliate links is about making money upon traffic directed elsewhere..so I guess donating is more honest to me. At least then I am not making money of what people click on.

Hmm, ok :)
Title: Re: Donate Button Does Good
Post by: lebisol on October 12, 2007, 03:57:48 AM
Thanks for your comments,
It is intersting to see both sides of the story...marketing vs. donating.
Thanks for your time!
Title: Re: Donate Button Does Good
Post by: 2bz2p on October 12, 2007, 04:29:17 AM
Hi,
 
     Let me first say that its not about the money, though it is helpful.

     I personally keep both, I have 1 set of ads that is in between the body and the menu and I use a treasury mod that I came across thanks to [cbl]Drifter site. I have not received any donations and minimal amount from the ads. Though every little bit helps and I intend on asking my members to pitch in 2-5 bucks when the server dues come up. The good thing about donations is 25 people donate a 1.00 you get $25, which I personally dont think its that much money considering most americans will not pick up the penny they see on the ground.

     I will say that no I would not sit on the side of the road asking people for a buck and/or hold a sign that says I will work for food. Though I do not mind asking for a donation to keep a website up and running that is soley there for its members.

Just My 2 Cents.
2B
Title: Re: Donate Button Does Good
Post by: G6Cad on October 12, 2007, 08:12:57 AM
A donation for the site it self i think never came through on my donation block, but a donation for work i have done for other sites have worked good. Also private donations for me or Dennis have also been made there.
But there is more to it then just begging, I use my button on my site for members that pay for help, they use it and it's also what they ask for when they want to pay for the help given. Although it's been a great while since it's been used now, it's just not a "begging" button, it's a secure pay method for those that want to have control over their money when they gladly pay to get things worked out on their sites :)
Title: Re: Donate Button Does Good
Post by: Zetan on October 12, 2007, 09:00:11 AM
I have no problem with a donate button and have had several members contribute.
It can work if you give something in return.. A shiny Subscriber badge if they subscribe.. they also feature on our Team rosta as a subscriber and they also have a subscriber only board.

I know a few sites that run "Subscriber" only competitions and they can win some pretty good gifts, an MP3 player for example.. and good one too, not a £5.99 job.
That site does have many subscribers, but they still aren't enough to justify the cost of the prizes.

If you can afford to run a competition once in a while for subscribers.. they feel valued.
If it's just a donation, I always ask if they want their username added to the list of people who have donated.
Title: Re: Donate Button Does Good
Post by: keith021773 on October 12, 2007, 02:26:41 PM
I run the donation mod (paypal) on my site for the last 2 mths and I must say it helps alot.   I don't feel like I'm begging because I don't.    I even tell people that they don't have to donate.   But, donations help alot with the cost of the server and if more donations come in then there is a very good chance of me being able to buy something and have a giveway..  A "thanks" for donating and being a member.

I have always said that my site isn't about money, it's about helping dads... either by helping them with their problems about parenting or marriage or by just being a place where they can "hang out" with other dads..    But if they want to donate because they like the site, then that's great.  I appreciate it and when they do donate, I always send them a PM telling them how thankful I am and that it helps alot..

That's just what I think...
Title: Re: Donate Button Does Good
Post by: lebisol on October 12, 2007, 05:22:23 PM
Thanks people,
Devil pays well, so I am going to keep pushing.
You should not ask for donations if:
1. you installed csm/forum
2. purchased template
3. purchased a hosting plan

where exactly do you feel like the people need to give back?
for your desire to design? for the posts that other members post?

The question to ask 'before asking' is what do you give them as Host?

Just the other other day I stumbled across the site that had a header link to Section called "Help me maintain this site". LOL
Sure, I liked the photos but hey the author took them because she liked taking photos. Period.

Imagine if I invested over $150,000 into a custom race car (that now I can not afford) and then drove around with a sticker that said "Help me continue to commute in this car...if you like to see it on the road"
hmm how many of you would reach for the wallet?  >:D

Well, the point of the post is to see and have people give some thought of why certain things are on our sites. Is it because you (us) as designer like it or see function for it....or is it that deep down inside we hope to make money doing it.
I wish we had some marketing gurus in here to break a few things down. It is scary how much is invested in subliminal advertisements and what people see - do.

And a of course, thanks for sharing your thoughts!
Title: Re: Donate Button Does Good
Post by: IchBin on October 12, 2007, 07:36:23 PM
In some sense I tend to disagree lebisol. The difference in your analogy with the car, is that if you had a "help me pay for this car sign", you damn well better let me drive it. lol In the case of websites, its not totally dependent on what you offer IMO, but the fact that you put your time and effort into it and they are enjoying he fruits of your labors.
Title: Re: Donate Button Does Good
Post by: lebisol on October 12, 2007, 07:48:37 PM
Quoteyou damn well better let me drive it.
:laugh: :'( :laugh:
nice one, you made my day and you are right.
Title: Re: Donate Button Does Good
Post by: Zetan on October 12, 2007, 07:48:56 PM
I would hope if you were driving such a car, you would have Sponsorship.
Title: Re: Donate Button Does Good
Post by: lebisol on October 12, 2007, 08:09:04 PM
same can be said for the site...if you could afford to build it...you should be able to afford to maintain it.
"Devil devil is my name..." said Danzig LOL
Title: Re: Donate Button Does Good
Post by: 2bz2p on October 12, 2007, 08:27:29 PM
   When someone says the word beggar, it reminds me of being in Red Square, Moscow, Russia. While I was sitting there I watched a "gypsy" walk up to me and say no words, but rather point at her feet that had no shoes on them, point at her mouth, and point at her baby on her back. I being on a school type trip was told not to give any money to "gypsies", so I didn’t and as she walked away I watched her walk all the way across the square and get into a fairly new Crown Victoria and drive away, black one to be exact. So with that said if I was in this for the money, I think that I would make more money begging for it in some tourist trap area.

     I state this because I would not beg anyone for money, it’s just not my style. But I do feel that if one of the members of the site, thought they should donate money for my time and expenses, then I am not begging am I, but receiving payment for services rendered, (if it were to be into a business Sense).

2B


     
Title: Re: Donate Button Does Good
Post by: Zetan on October 12, 2007, 08:29:02 PM
ahh.. Danzig!
I can afford to maintain it.. but I wouldn't refuse a contribution.

It makes no odds whether people donate, or not.. in truth. I wouldn't do it otherwise.
My site costs.. my stream host costs.. at this time, I can afford it.

I can live without a Donate button.. and I still don't consider it begging, though I can clearly see exactly where you are coming from.
A professional site should not need such a visable sign of needing "help".

Thats a choice made by individual sites.
Title: Re: Donate Button Does Good
Post by: lebisol on October 12, 2007, 08:38:12 PM
I think that last 2 posts sum up my personal stand the best!

p.s. @Zetan....wow HM...so long ago...my 1st vinal record was Motorhead then AC/DC (stolen from my brother hihihi)
Title: Re: Donate Button Does Good
Post by: Zetan on October 12, 2007, 08:49:09 PM
haha  ;D

Seriously though.. I use FREE forum software, as do you.. so what does that say?

For me it says that I love the freedom, the community and that I like to play..
It has nothing to do with money.. If you choose not to display a Donate button.. I'll go with that, I'm sure many established sites wouldn't openly.

All I'm saying is, if you feel you want to openly display a "Donate here, please, coz we need it" button, then, no site will survive on donations alone. It's really a choice..
I make no money from ads.. I know several sites that swear by having "No Ads"... thats their choice, I wouldn't personally use it as a tact to draw members..
Either you do, or you don't.. Server costs are irrelevant to be honest.. you have already made that choice to pay for server costs.