Knat says: I did not write this article, i found it here (http://www.alistapart.com/articles/identitymatters). I think it is very good to read and maybe it will inspire some of you in a good way. Enjoy the article :)
Anonymity and Online Community: Identity Matters
Many popular websites such as Wikipedia offer little differentiation between the experience and tools available to registered users and to anonymous visitors. Many active users of such websites may, therefore, be virtually unknown to their hosts. As most party hosts knows, itââ,¬â,,¢s usually the people who just ââ,¬Å"show upââ,¬Â and that you donââ,¬â,,¢t know who can create the biggest headaches. As Wikipediaââ,¬â,,¢s recent scandals demonstrate, this decision poses several site-management headaches. Well-designed membership systems can allow community managers to head off trouble before it hits the national news. This article provides an understanding of why online identity matters and offers six steps to help you build stronger online communities.
Anonymity Can Wreak Havoc in a CommunityAnonymity is a double-edged sword when it comes to an online community. While anonymity may allow people to feel more free and disinhibited to discuss otherwise embarrassing or stigmatizing topics, it can also be a communityââ,¬â,,¢s biggest enemy. Anonymity allows people to hide behind their computers while saying whatever they want with little ramification. Psychologists know that online community is far more disinhibited than face-to-face communications.1, 2, 3 Pair that disinhibition with anonymity and you have a recipe for potential disaster.
Some websites have discovered fairly innovative ways to allow for anonymity, but still filter out the disinhibited negative behaviors that often come with it. Slashdot, an old technology community weblog, has long had a moderation system that allows registered users to vote on the quality of comments in an article. So even if a user chooses to post something anonymously (for whatever reasons), that comment may still be considered of sufficient quality to be read by others.
Pseudonymityââ,¬â€anonymity that hides a person behind an online persona via a usernameââ,¬â€is common online. Many internet users have a number of different identities they use online, to allow them to explore different aspects of their persona, interests or hobbies. But pseudonymity is also the key to membership systems as well, as it allows members of the community to learn to identify other members they like or dislike based upon their behaviors and personality. Pseudononymous systems strike a balance between peopleââ,¬â,,¢s needs to obscure their identities online, while still allowing them to build reputations in those usernames. These systems have been shown to work very well for an online community.
People build reputations in their usernames, and so their reputation becomes something they value and want to protect. Members who have an investment in something within your community are far less likely to blow that investment through inappropriate, negative behavior.
Freedom to the MassesLetââ,¬â,,¢s use Wikipedia as our example. Up until very recently, they were an almost completely open, registration-free system. Thereââ,¬â,,¢s no formal system of checks or balances built-in that ensures the information is factual, much less not libelous or fictitious. That is its biggest strength and one of its biggest weaknesses. It relies on the sheer numbers of others visiting the site to act as fact-checkers and editors. It is generally believed that Wikipedia offers a semblance of credible, reliable information that compares with similar types of information sources.4, 5, 6 But before it implemented its current registration requirements, anybody couldââ,¬â€and didââ,¬â€add anything to the site, of any quality, and with no ramification or fear of discovery for antisocial behavior. Because Wikipedia didnââ,¬â,,¢t care who its users were, it had only limited and blunt tools to fix community problems that cropped up (such as completely locking an article to stop anyone else from editing it).
Member versus VisitorWhen you establish a relationship with members, youââ,¬â,,¢re more likely to get valuable, useful information and responsible behavior from them. Theyââ,¬â,,¢re invested in the service precisely because they are members. And membership, as American Express has been extolling for decades, has its privileges. If thereââ,¬â,,¢s little difference between a websiteââ,¬â,,¢s ââ,¬Å"memberââ,¬Â and a random visitor to the site (e.g., they can both do a lot of the exact same things), then most users have little incentive to become a member (or ââ,¬Å"registered userââ,¬Â in web-speak).
Wikipediaââ,¬â,,¢s recent reaction to the revelation that Congressional staffers were editing the heck out of their politicianââ,¬â,,¢s bios (and those of their opponents) is also pretty telling. Their only choice was to shut down editing access to whole blocks of IP addresses (IP addresses identify specific computers connected to the Internet at any point in time). Wikipedia, not really knowing who most of its editing users actually are, had very little granularity available to them to control access to their most prized possessionââ,¬â€their data. So they had to block everybody in this block of IPs, including innocent users. The users who were acting responsibly and within Wikipediaââ,¬â,,¢s guidelines were also blocked if they happened to be accessing the site from another of those offices in the same building. (The block has since been lifted.)